Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Diane Love (St Petersburg FL)'s avatar

I’m so looking forward to your book. Michener also wrote some sweeping, historical multigenerational epics.

The battle between autocracy and democracy continues to shape our world.

Barry Kent MacKay's avatar

"This work of historical fiction I’m working on will do what no other work save Birth of A Nation and Gone With The Wind has attempted to do which is to create a narrative that ties the antebellum period to Reconstruction well into Jim crow and connect it to Nazi Germany. I know what you’re thinking. You can’t possibly connect completely different eras using the same characters." Respectfully, nope...you don't (and can't) know what I'm thinking. I have long believed in that connection and in fact am burdened (more cursed than blessed) with seeing connectivity that others just don't get. But my life, now close to over, grew out of different soil than your life, so I invariably might view things differently, not that the connection described does not exist -- you and I believe it certainly does, but that I first run all human actions through the lens of evolutionary psychology - did what seems irrational have survival value no longer needed, and possibly counter-productive. I am aware that my answer to that question may be filtered through my own unconscious confirmation bias -- which becomes conscious by virtue of my recognizing it may exist. But I have never (at least since maturity and growing awareness of our species overall collective nuttiness has led me into research and thoughtfulness about such things) denied the other factor, the nurturing part. Not every white descendant of slave owners who lives in rural Mississippi is a de facto white supremacist (or so I think, never having knowingly met such a person). What I'm trying to say in my excessive verbosity (sorry) is that I think the connectedness goes far, far, beyond the U.S. and Germany, or between the Holocaust and the present. If I were religious I'd think that it was a case of the devil vs God, with the former sometimes able to take the disguise of the latter, in a continual struggle for ultimate control. But I'm agnostic, and first look for a Newtonian cause-and-effect relationship with what we have inherited from who we were tens of thousands of years ago. I just read about scientists finding two groups of Chimpanzees engaging in "civil war". Exactly. Did not protohumans do the same? Impossible to say. On the other hand, there seems to be no such behavior in Bonobos, who are more closely related to Chimps than we are, BUT, are also more closely related to us than are Chimpanzees, according to DNA analysis. So enter the nurture part, I guess, whereby evil flourishes where evil is. Evil, thus defined, serves a purpose that no longer exists. We are not who we were when heritable traits were being selected for, and the distrust of "the other", even based on the most minimal of trivialities, is now counter-productive....um...in my opinion.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?