Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Diane Love (St Petersburg FL)'s avatar

Remarkable Xavier, you’ve taken bothsideism and transformed it into a useful tool for intellectual rigor and clarity. Regarding the attack on Venezuela, this essay along with Timothy Snyder’s and Robert Arnold’s essays on Substack today, have given me more insight than everything else I’ve read on mainstream news sources. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Barry Kent MacKay's avatar

Excellent work (and a lot of it; well done).

When I first heard the news of whatever you want to call what was done, it was from American sources and left me with the initial impression that no weaponry had been brought into play and no one had been hurt. Of course I soon learned otherwise, but, speaking cynically as a non-American, yeah, lives were lost, but not AMERICAN lives (as people in the U.S. define "American", but that's another issue) so it didn't make the first news. Or maybe in the fog of...again whatever you want to call it...the concern about getting the story out fast precluded knowledge of the violence that had, in fact, occurred.

When I read news stories I do as you advise, and seek many viewpoints, but what really interests me is informed commentary...the subjective views of various experts in relevant fields.

The trouble here is that commentary cannot be very "informed" for two reasons -- the opacity of the current regime, or, if you prefer, administration, precludes the information required. But I think of even greater importance is the fact that we can only speculate on, but not predict, the future.

Past adventures of this nature -- each being individualistic, thus different from each other, suggests that for Venezuelan citizens there will likely be no good come of it -- a frying pan to fire situation -- and for most American citizens, ditto. There is a good chance, I think, that absurdly wealthy Americans will become much more wealthy, a function of war, but they are not my concern.

As a Canadian of course I worry about the fact that a system that has protected us since WWII is now being broken by the country most in a position to break it. It is a sad truth that we are in what in a secular sense (or so I believe) is a war between -- again anything I say will reflect my own bias -- the rule of law on one hand, and the might-makes-right paradigm favored by those who have, or think they have, the might on their side. It has been thus since history was first recorded. Trump is, I think, trying to turn the U.S. into what Britain, or Rome for that matter, more recently, Germany either were, or tried to be. It does not bode well.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?